Grilled Nashville Hot Chicken Mac and Cheese uses that spicy hot Smoked Nashville Whole Chicken to make mac and cheese with some zing!

Nashville Hot Chicken Mac and Cheese

If you are unfamiliar with Nashville-style spiced chicken, it is a supremely spicy chicken that makes your eyes water and your mouth burn, and it is worth every hot tingling moment!

If you aren’t scared of heat, Nashville chicken mac and cheese is the answer. The cheese sauce and the pasta both help to bring the temperature down a few degrees. So, it is spicy, but not “run to the sink and turn on the faucet to extinguish the fire” hot.

Check out all of my Traeger Recipes!

How to make Nashville Hot Chicken Mac and Cheese

This mac and cheese recipe is basically the same as my one-pot creamy noodle recipe. The big difference comes in using Spiceology Nashville rub on everything! This spicy rub seasons the sauce, it seasons the chicken, and it even seasons the crumbs on top!

The triple play of this wonderfully spicy rub brings the heat. Of course, if you want to cut the heat a notch or two, then sprinkle less in the sauce or the bread crumbs for the top. You can let the spice rub on the chicken do all the work, adding heat if you want.

Just don’t be surprised to find yourself sprinkling some of it on anyway.

More Easy Traeger Recipes here!

What kind of cheese works best for this dish?

In my one-pot creamy noodle recipe, I recommend using parmesan or mozzarella. About half and half of each of those is ideal. The parmesan adds a bit of funky umami and a bit of saltiness. Then mozzarella comes through with the creamy goodness.

Of course, you could also use a variety of other cheeses as well.

With the super spicy Nashville rub, don’t be afraid to use a bit of blue cheese and some cheddar. The English cheese called Stilton is essentially a sharp cheddar-style cheese that has veins of blue cheese in it.

You could also use Mexican Oaxacan-style cheese, which is similar to mozzarella, and some cotija cheese, which is similar to parmesan.

The key is balancing the creaminess with a little funk, since those will play off the hot spices nicely.

The point is, you can customize this with whatever cheese you have on hand, really, so experiment a bit!

Get my easy Side Dish recipes!

Nashville Grilled Chicken

Grilled Nashville chicken gets the superheat from being coated in a cayenne-infused hot oil. The hot oil helps the cayenne seep into every single taste bud and makes them scream for mercy.

With Spiceology’s Nashville Hot Chicken rub, you can easily create the flavors of Nashville chicken and keep the heat. But you don’t have to worry about creating hot cayenne-infused oil to dunk the chicken in.

I recommend using my Smoked Nashville Hot Chicken recipe. You can also bake the chicken with the Nashville Spiceology rub if you prefer the convenience, or you can grill chicken breasts with the spicy rub.

Follow me on Instagram!

What kind of pasta works best for this recipe?

Ideally, the best pasta for Mac and Cheese can easily coat and hold a bit of cheese sauce in it. I like penne noodles myself, but if you want to use macaroni or shells, that is fine too. I do recommend using the larger-sized shells if you are going to go that route.

Penne is the tube-shaped noodles, and they come in several sizes as well. If you are shopping for them, then I recommend the mid-sized ones.

You want the pasta to be sized sort of equally to the bits of spiced chicken you are adding in.

Get all of my easy dessert recipes here!

How do you store the leftovers?

If you do have any leftovers handy, then keep them in a plastic container that is microwave-proof. That way you can conveniently serve them easily with quick zap in the mic.

The noodles will keep up to a week.

If you want to keep that crunchy top you can also reheat in the oven or the air fryer.

While you can freeze them, I don’t highly recommend it. The noodles lose their texture and don’t do well with freezing, defrosting, and reheating. It won’t taste bad, but it just won’t be as “wow” as when you first served it, or if you just ate the refrigerated leftovers.

Featured Reader Reviews

“My 4th time making this by request. This mac & cheese is fabulous. Not spicy hot, just amazing flavor since you boil the pasta in the water, milk, butter and seasoning. Made it for a Christmas Eve gathering with hot roast beef sandwiches. Perfect combo. It’s now one of my go-to recipes.”

– Lori from Pinterest

What can you serve with Nashville Hot Chicken Mac and Cheese?

You can do grilled Nashville hot chicken mac and cheese as an entree or a side no problem. If you serve it as a main course, then I can recommend a few salads to go with it.

• Greek Salad
• Caesar salad dressing
• Caprese salad

And if you serve it on the side, then I recommend serving it with any of these hearty dishes that can stand up to the spicy chicken.

• Griddle patty melt
• Sweet chili chicken quarters
• Homemade shake and bake pork chops

Make something delicious for dessert!